DVD review from The Movie Snob.
Community – Season Three. (B-) Quick refresher: Jeffrey Winger (Joel McHale, The Informant!) is a slick ex-lawyer who has been disbarred because he never got a college degree. So he has enrolled at Greendale Community College to earn a degree and hopefully get his law license back. Way back in the pilot episode, he inadvertently formed a study group with five lovable misfits—plus a rich old geezer named Pierce Hawthorne (Chevy Chase, Caddyshack), who is not lovable at all. The show is all about the study group’s escapades, and it’s full of absurdist humor about how terrible a school Greendale is. I strongly urge you to get a hold of Season One and give it a try.
Unfortunately, Season Three is not as good as Season One and Season Two. John Goodman (O Brother Where Art Thou) has a recurring role as the dean of Greendale’s air-conditioning-repair school, and the season-long plot arc in which he attempts to recruit Troy is just not very funny. Somewhat funnier is Abed’s season-long obsession with a British TV show called Inspector Timespace (a transparent Dr. Who clone). Early on there’s a really interesting episode in which the gang is gathered in Troy and Abed’s apartment for a housewarming party, and when the pizza delivery arrives they roll a die to decide who has to go downstairs to get it. For the rest of the episode they play that scenario out seven different ways, depending on who goes to get the pizza—kind of a butterfly-effect sort of thing. There’s also a funny episode that is an homage to Law & Order, right down to the theme music. And they get pretty good results repeating a gimmick from the second season: a clip show in which all the “clips” being remembered by the characters are actually brand-new scenes. But lots of episodes fall flat, like a Christmas episode done Glee-style, and one in which Shirley and Jeff take on some German foosball bullies. My favorite character, the cute and ambitious Annie Edison (Alison Brie, The Five-Year Engagement) has some decent episodes. I thought Britta (Gillian Jacobs, Seeking a Friend for the End of the World) got a little cheated on screen time, but her bits tended to be very funny when she was on.
As I understand it, Community barely escaped cancellation after the third season, the network fired series creator Dan Harmon, and they are now airing a shortened 13-episode fourth season. And last I heard a fifth season was still a possibility. I’m crossing my fingers and hoping they get their groove back.