From The Movie Snob.
The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug (B). Well, I feel like I liked this movie better than I liked the first installment of The Hobbit, but I see now that I gave both movies a “B.” Of course, the movie is way too long, at 2 hours and 41 minutes, but the events and incidents seem weightier than the ones that crowded the first movie. Part of the padding is that Peter Jackson shows what happens when Gandalf (Ian McKellen, Gods and Monsters) goes off alone to confront an evil sorcerer called “the Necromancer,” which as I recall happens entirely “off-stage” in the novel. But the main story is still about a small band of dwarves wanting to take their ancestral kingdom under The Lonely Mountain back from Smaug, the terrifying dragon that occupied it some decades ago. Hobbit Bilbo Baggins (Martin Freeman, The World’s End) proves himself invaluable as their hired thief. Smaug is a pretty impressive feat of CGI (voice of Benedict Cumberbatch, 12 Years a Slave). And I have no quarrel with the casting of the lovely Evangeline Lilly (The Hurt Locker) as non-Tolkien character Tauriel the Elf Warrior. But the movie certainly could have been shorter.